Win an Instant Vortex Plus 10 Quart Air Fryer, Rotisserie, and Convection Oven! →

Buttermilk Pie

It’s like creme brulee in a pie shell!

It’s hard to forget your first bite of buttermilk pie. Custardy and sweet with a golden brown top, it’ll remind you of a creme brûlée in a pie shell. It’s so good it’s just no wonder this Southern delight has lasted through the years. Buttermilk pie has a history so long, it’s hard to tell where it really began, though it’s safe to say it’s pretty much always been a part of our culinary culture.

The pie originally came from England, but it became popular with settlers in the United States right from the get go and has been a mainstay along the Mason-Dixon line for decades and decades. It’s among the tradition of “desperation pies” or “make-do pies”: desserts that used common pantry ingredients to create a homey and delicious treat when (whether because of expense or scarcity) there weren’t a lot of other options for ingredients. Buttermilk Pie could be made year-round when fruit wasn’t available for a pie filling, but it’s so good that we doubt anyone really missed that fruit!

Even today, it’s common to see this pie set out at the Thanksgiving table in Texas. While it might seem odd to base a pie off of tart buttermilk, there’s just nothing else like it. (Just think, would it have stuck around this long if it wasn’t totally amazing?) While this pie is born out of a waste not, want not mindset using up residual buttermilk after butter had been made, it certainly doesn’t taste like an afterthought. This sugary pie has a unique flavor all its own and everyone should try it at least once. (But we promise you won’t stop there!)

Serves 6-8

1 hour

  • 1 9-inch pie crust, unbaked
  • 3 tablespoon all-purpose flour
  • 2 cups granulated sugar
  • 1 cup buttermilk
  • 1/2 cup (1 stick) unsalted butter, softened
  • 3 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  1. Preheat oven to 350°F.
  2. In a medium bowl, beat together butter and sugar with an electric mixer on medium until light and fluffy. Add the flour and eggs and mix to combine.
  3. Mix in the buttermilk, nutmeg, salt, and vanilla, and mix until thoroughly incorporated.
  4. Pour into unbaked pie shell and bake until center is set and top is browned, about 45 minutes. Let cool completely before slicing and serving. Enjoy!

Adapted from Kasey Trenum.

Subscribe to 12 Tomatoes